and Queen (France;
directed by: Arnaud Desplechin
starring: Emmanuelle Devos; Mathieu Amalric; Catherine Deneuve
|Chris says: "Even though it seems like a fairly
conventional dialog-rich character study on the surface, this is really
a strange, complex little film, if subtly so. It tells parallel stories
of two ex-lovers: Nora (Emanuelle Devos) and Ismael (Mathieu Almaric).
Nora's a single mother who is about to be married to Jean-Jacques (Olivier
Rabourdin), a successful if dour businessman. Her father, Louis (Maurice
Garrel), has just found out he has terminal cancer.
Meanwhile, Ismael is a talented, if unhinged concert violist who has been committed to an asylum. There, he begins an impulsive affair with a fellow suicidal patient, Arielle (Magalie Waloch). Most of this actually plays out like the comedy to Nora's impending tragedy. The two stories eventually entangle when Nora asks Ismael (rather than Jean-Jacques) to legally adopt her son, Elias (Valentin Lelong).
This is the basic plot, but KINGS AND QUEENS veers all over the map, making room for cameos (Catherine Deneuve appears as a weathered yet demure psychiatrist), flashbacks (we learn about the accidental death of her son Elias' father, Pierre (Joachim Salinger) via memories and possible dream sequences), supporting characters who occasionally steal the show (like Dr. Devereux (the wonderful Elsa Woliaston), Ismael's imposing therapist) and surreal, diverting scenes that seem apropos of the main story.
However, on the whole, Arnaud Despelchin's film is not all that random. Although it often veers between screwball comedy and something approaching grand Shakespearian melodrama, smooth enough to the point where it doesn't feel at all jarring, KINGS AND QUEENS is an intricate set of narrative and atmospheric rhymes--listen for the latter in the musical cues. At 150 minutes, it's about a half-hour too long, but that final half-hour is the film's strongest, especially when the focus is on Ismael (Almaric's performance is nomination-worthy), his family (who are barely seen up to that point), and the touching, masterful conversation he has with Elias. 4 cats"
|Hilary says: "This is definitely a worth seeing -- hie
thee to the Brattle, Boston-area Chlotrudis folk!
"It does lose momentum in the last half-hour, dragging my rating down from 5 cats to 4, but you'll be kicking yourself if you miss Mathieu Almaric's performance as eccentric, charming, pathological, professional viol-player Ismakl, particularly the scenes with his family."