(USA; 114 min.)
directed by: Spike Jonze
starring: Nicholas Cage; Meryl Streep; Chris Cooper; Tilda Swinton; Cara Seymour
|Mary W. says:
"ADAPTATION had a lot of laughs but definitely all in the flip meandering
mode so that after a time the one-note characters-"Charlie Kaufman" (Nicholas
Cage) and "Susan Orlean" (Meryl Steep) begin to wear thin. I never tired
of Charlie's feckless brother Donald, however. And Chris Cooper does full
justice to the incredible character of John Leroche, really the only element
of the book to make it into the movie intact.
"Some of the flights of fancy-the answer to the question to 'Why am I here,' for example, and Charlie's descriptions in botanicalese of women at an orchid show-were really fresh and funny. And I actually enjoyed the controversial B-movie wrap-up."
"ADAPTATION is Charlie Kaufman and Spike Jonze's eagerly awaited follow-up
to their award-winning film, BEING
JOHN MALKOVICH. In this curious film, Charlie Kaufman (played by Nicholas
Cage) struggles with the task of adapting Susan Orlean's non-fiction book,
The Orchid Thief into a movie while hosting his twin brother Donald
as he works on his own screenplay. Sound simple? Well, that synopsis is
light years from what is actually contained in the film.
" But I don't want to go too far into the plot. I think ADAPTATION is definitely a film that suffers from knowing too much. As I watched the film, I found myself wishing I didn't know certain things as they played out. When the credits rolled, I really had to think about what I thought of ADAPTATION. Initially, I was disappointed. I wanted something as innovative and wacky as BEING JOHN MALKOVICH, and ADAPTATION is a very different animal indeed. Ultimately, I really liked the way ADAPTATION plays with the ideas of what is "real" and what is fiction in this screenplay that superficially could be based on fact. Kaufman rants about all the things he doesn't want to do in this movie, then proceeds to do each and every one of them. It's definitely a thought-provoker that provokes a lot of post-film discussion.
"Above it all, the performances were superb. Nicholas Cage (who I haven't liked in a long time) was superb as Charlie, insecure, genius screenwriter who is terrified at interacting with people. But he's even better as the oblivious, outgoing Donald. Each time he meekly accepts a cutting remark from Charlie, I just winced with sympathy. Meryl Streep as Susan Orleans brings both gravity and a subtle comic presence. There is a scene where she is brushing her teeth that was priceless. Chris Cooper, as John Laroche, the "orchid thief" of Orleans' book, is delightfully eccentric, yet tragically grounded. ADAPTATION is filled with delightful supporting performances from indie faves Tilda Swinton as a high-powered studio exec, Maggie Gyllenhaal as a sweet make-up girl on the set of BEING JOHN MALKOVICH, Brian Cox as screenwriter Robert McKee and most notably, Cara Seymour (so wonderful in DANCER IN THE DARK and AMERICAN PSYCHO) as Amelia, Charlie's friend and secret object of his affections.
"Charlie Kaufman is certainly a talent to be mindful of, and his collaborations with Jonze are wonderfully, wild rides." 4 cats
|Peg says: "I must HIGHLY recommend ADAPTATION! Amazingly funny, bitingly satirical, erudite, extremely moving and just plain weird. So nice to see Spike Jonze and Charlie Kaufman working together again. I even liked Nic Cage! This one makes BEING JOHN MALKOVICH look like WATERWORLD...wait. no. nothing could be thaaaaat bad..."|
says: "Nicolas Cage does double duty as twin brothers Charlie and Donald
Kaufman. As chronic worrier Charlie bemoans his lack of inspiration in making
a screenplay out of Orchid Thief, his down-on-his-luck but always-cheerful
brother Donald begs to be allowed to stay in his apartment until he gets
on his feet. Not too bright Donald, motivated by his brother's gig in Hollywood,
decides that he, too, shall write a screenplay of his own - about a schizophrenic
serial killer who is also the cop assigned to hunt himself down. As his
twin blasts through his script and gets serious Tinsel town attention, Charlie
fails to get a handle on Orleans's self-involving story about John Laroche,
the colorful title character of her book.
"As Charlie unravels the complex relationship between Laroche and Orleans, whose book tries to unravel the mind of the subject character, he becomes mired and confused on just how to tell the story. After going through reams of paper and months of effort, Kaufman has nothing to show his producers. He sinks into despair and battles with his writer's block until he has an epiphany - interweave his own problems into the screenplay about adapting a book he finds impossible to adapt. The result is a wild, complicates story with many layers, moods and feelings.
"The film ADAPTATION is structured on three levels - the story of the man, John Laroche, an intelligent rebel who has tried his hand at everything (mostly illegal) from collecting undersea creatures to poaching rare orchids from protected areas to running an internet porn site; the tale of Susan Orleans and her initial New Yorker magazine article about Laroche and the struggles and emotions she experienced with the man while adapting her article to book length; and, Charlie's own plight (with brother Donald providing a fresh-faced, funny attitude about life as the comic relief). The wonderfully complex tapestry of (the real) Charlie Kaufman's script weaves these threads together into a true filmic experience.
"Nicolas Cage, in his dual role, gets a chance to shine in his best performance since LEAVING LAS VEGAS. His characters are distinctly different in personality and temperament. It doesn't take long, as Charlie and Donald work and live in the same space, to forget that you are watching the actor and believe in the characters he creates. Where Charlie exists in a fog of despair all the time, Donald lives in the basking warmth of the rays of life's sun. Cage is a short-list candidate for considerable award attention in his no-holds-barred perf as fat and bald Charlie and Donald. They are two sides of the same coin and Cage plays them both with great skill.
"The two main supporting players, Cooper and Streep, are first-rate as Laroche and Orleans. Chris Cooper in particular proves once again that he is one of America's finest character actors as he delivers nuance in his portrayal of the orchid thief, Laroche, and gives depth to the man. Even with his front teeth knocked out, Laroche is still an attractive man and lustful adventurer who grasps an object of his interest with dedicated passion only to drop it like a hot potato when something else peaks his fervor. Meryl Streep takes a step back from her usual commanding screen presence and lets her leading men have the limelight but is convincing and 3-dimensional as Susan. Tilda Swinton and Maggie Gyllenhaal, in small supporting roles, are background characters only.
"Writer Kaufman hits another home run with one of the most imaginative, intelligent and witty scripts of the year. The lines blur and redefine constantly as the story bounce back and forth through a period of years, showing John and his poaching pals, Susan as she unravels John's story, Charlie and his plight and back again to John. The main thread of Charlie coping with his block is the underlying theme, though, and Cage anchors the film with it. Kaufman also uses the maguffin of the mysterious "ghost orchid" as a hook into the psyche of Laroche but also as a tool to inform the viewer of the nature of the species, its exotic appearance and its appeal to the passionate collectors. This is one richly crafted screenplay.
"Sophomore helmer Spike Jonze follows up his successful first feature with a work that shows that he is a talent to be reckoned with. He handles Kaufman's script and its richly drawn characters and puts you into the mind of Charlie and gives an intimate look into the obsession of Orleans as she learns about and falls for John. Jonze deftly weaves the colorful and interesting story threads written by Kaufman with his talented cast and brings it to quirky life on the big screen.
"ADAPTATION is a film buff's dream." 5 cats